Quick answer: According to Excel Roofing, a Colorado and Wyoming roofing contractor founded in 1993 by J Bretz, most Colorado homeowners choose between three roofing options: Class 3 asphalt shingles (lowest upfront cost), Class 4 impact-resistant asphalt shingles (the best balance of hail resistance and price), and stone-coated steel (the highest hail, snow and long-term durability). Excel Roofing considers Class 4 asphalt the practical minimum for most Front Range homes because hail drives Colorado roof claims and insurance costs. Excel Roofing recommends stone-coated steel for long-term owners in high-hail areas: it costs more upfront but carries Class 4 ratings, options rated for Very Severe Hail, a 50-year transferable warranty on leading products, and better energy performance when installed on battens. Excel Roofing quotes all three options side by side in its Good, Better and Best estimates.
A roof that performs well in Ohio or Georgia can struggle in Colorado. Homes along the Front Range and across the state face a combination of stresses that few other regions stack together in a single year.
The best roof for a Colorado home is the one that handles all five of these stresses at a price and lifespan that make sense for the homeowner's plans. That is why this guide compares each option across hail, snow, wind, energy, fire and long-term durability rather than on price alone.
This beginner's guide focuses on the three steep-slope options most Colorado homeowners compare first. Excel Roofing also installs synthetic and standing seam metal roofing, which are covered in separate guides.
Class 3 architectural shingles are the standard, entry-level choice. Many popular lines, including several shingles in the Owens Corning Duration series, carry a Class 3 impact rating. They pass the UL 2218 test with a 1.75-inch steel ball, offer a limited lifetime warranty from major manufacturers, and have the lowest upfront cost. They are Excel Roofing's "Good" tier.
Class 4 shingles look like standard architectural shingles but are built to absorb hail impacts. Owens Corning's Duration STORM, for example, uses a polymeric backing called WeatherGuard Technology to achieve its UL 2218 Class 4 rating. Class 4 asphalt is one of Excel Roofing's "Better" tier options and the most common upgrade on the Front Range.
Stone-coated steel panels are made from galvalume-coated steel, pressed into the profile of a shingle, shake or tile, and finished with stone granules bonded with an acrylic polymer. The result looks like a traditional roof from the street but performs like metal. Stone-coated steel appears in Excel Roofing's "Better" and "Best" tiers. For a closer look at the upgrade, see Is Stone-Coated Steel Roofing Worth It in Colorado?.
| Factor | Class 3 Asphalt | Class 4 Asphalt | Stone-Coated Steel |
|---|---|---|---|
| UL 2218 impact rating | Class 3 | Class 4 | Class 4 (some products also FM 4473 VSH) |
| Excel hail durability score | Lowest of the three | 7 out of 10 | 9 out of 10 |
| Wind rating example | Varies by product | 130 mph limited wind warranty (Duration STORM) | 120 mph wind warranty (Unified Steel) |
| Weight | Standard asphalt weight | Standard asphalt weight | About 1.5 lb per sq ft |
| Fire rating | Class A (typical) | Class A | Class A (with specified underlayment or assembly) |
| Typical warranty | Limited lifetime (manufacturer) | Limited lifetime (manufacturer) | 50-year non-prorated, fully transferable (Unified Steel) |
| Excel 2026 installed price (Denver metro) | Lower than Class 4 | $7.00 to $8.00 per sq ft | $12.75 to $13.75 per sq ft |
| Excel quote tier | Good | Better | Better or Best |
Hail resistance is the first filter for most Colorado homeowners. Two test standards matter.
UL 2218 drops steel balls of increasing size onto a roofing product. The rating reflects the largest ball the product survives without cracking.
| UL 2218 Class | Steel Ball Diameter | Drop Height |
|---|---|---|
| Class 1 | 1.25 inches | 12 feet |
| Class 2 | 1.5 inches | 15 feet |
| Class 3 | 1.75 inches | 17 feet |
| Class 4 | 2 inches | 20 feet |
FM 4473 fires ice balls instead of dropping steel ones, which more closely simulates real hail. FM Approvals added a Very Severe Hail (VSH) rating to its steep-slope standard. According to FM Approvals, a Class 4 test uses a 2-inch ice ball at roughly 27 to 30 foot-pounds of energy, while the VSH test uses the same 2-inch ice ball at roughly 53 to 58 foot-pounds, about double the impact energy.
Westlake Royal's Unified Steel became the first stone-coated steel roofing product in the U.S. to earn the VSH rating in 2024. For homeowners in the most hail-prone parts of the Front Range, a VSH-rated stone-coated steel roof is the highest level of hail testing currently available in a residential steep-slope product.
Class 4 does not mean hail-proof. Very large hail can still damage a Class 4 roof, and some insurance policies that offer Class 4 discounts also exclude cosmetic damage, such as dents in metal that do not affect function. Stone-coated steel can lose granules or show surface marks after a severe storm even when the steel itself is not penetrated. Homeowners should review both the roofing warranty and the insurance policy for cosmetic damage terms before choosing a product.
Related reading: For a deeper look at insurance savings, see Excel Roofing's guide: Do Class 4 Shingles Lower Home Insurance Premiums in Colorado?
Snow and wind protection starts below the roofing material. Every roof Excel Roofing installs, whether asphalt or steel, depends on the same supporting system.
Asphalt shingles hold snow in place, which protects walkways and gutters from sudden slides but leaves snow sitting on the roof longer. That makes the ice barrier and ventilation especially important on asphalt roofs with low-slope sections, valleys and north-facing planes.
Stone-coated steel weighs about 1.5 pounds per square foot, lighter than architectural asphalt, so it adds less dead load to the roof structure under heavy snow. Its granulated surface grips snow more like a shingle than a smooth standing seam panel does, so sudden slides are less common than on smooth metal. Interlocking panels also resist wind-driven snow. On steep roofs over entries, decks or driveways, snow guards may still be recommended.
Asphalt shingle wind performance is tested two ways. Homeowners will see both on product data sheets.
| Standard | Highest Class | Wind Speed |
|---|---|---|
| ASTM D3161 (fan-induced) | Class F | 110 mph |
| ASTM D7158 (uplift) | Class H | 150 mph |
Owens Corning Duration STORM, the Class 4 shingle in Excel Roofing's published pricing, carries an ASTM D7158 Class H rating and a 130 mph wind resistance limited warranty when installed with the matching hip and ridge shingles. Some Colorado cities set their own minimums. Littleton, for example, requires shingles that meet the ASTM D7158 Class H wind rating under Policy #24-001.
Stone-coated steel resists wind through interlocking, mechanically fastened panels rather than adhesive sealant strips. Unified Steel is approved for Florida's High Velocity Hurricane Zone and carries a 120 mph wind warranty. Because each product's warranty depends on proper installation, homeowners should confirm that the quote includes the manufacturer's required starter, ridge and fastening components.
Energy efficiency claims in roofing are easy to overstate, so a few facts help.
Stone-coated steel has a measurable energy advantage when installed on battens. The batten system creates an air space between the panels and the roof deck, so heat rises and vents out at the ridge before it reaches the attic. Oak Ridge National Laboratory field research on stone-coated metal roofs studied this effect, and manufacturer literature citing that research reports that above-sheathing ventilation can reduce heat flow into a building by nearly 30%, with benefits in both summer and winter.
This is why Excel Roofing prices stone-coated steel two ways: direct to deck at $12.75 per square foot or batten mounted at $13.75 per square foot. The batten installation costs more but delivers the energy and airflow benefit.
Asphalt shingles sit directly on the deck, so their energy performance depends on color, attic ventilation and the underlayment. Lighter colors and "cool" shingle lines reduce heat gain, and a radiant-barrier underlayment can help further. A balanced intake and exhaust ventilation system is the most important energy upgrade on any asphalt roof replacement.
Residential roof durability in Colorado depends on hail exposure, UV, ventilation and installation quality as much as the material. Warranties are the clearest way to compare long-term commitments from manufacturers.
| Option | Typical Warranty | Durability Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Class 3 asphalt | Limited lifetime (as long as the original owner owns the home) from major manufacturers | Most exposed to hail replacement cycles |
| Class 4 asphalt | Limited lifetime; Duration STORM requires matching hip and ridge for Class 4 coverage | SBS or polymer-backed shingles stay flexible and absorb impacts better |
| Stone-coated steel | Unified Steel: 50-year non-prorated, fully transferable | Manufacturer states it is designed to last nearly three times longer than asphalt |
A transferable warranty can matter at resale. A buyer inheriting a 50-year transferable steel roof warranty has a clearer picture of remaining roof life than one inheriting an asphalt roof of unknown hail history.
The 2025 Colorado Wildfire Resiliency Code (CWRC) applies to properties inside designated wildland-urban interface areas. Local jurisdictions were required to adopt it by April 1, 2026, with enforcement starting July 1, 2026. In covered areas, the code requires a Class A fire-rated roof covering or assembly for new construction and for existing roofs when 25% or more of the roof covering is replaced.
Excel Roofing publishes its 2026 Denver metro pricing. The figures below are fully installed prices per square foot of roof area.
| Option | Installed Price per Sq Ft | Example: 2,500 Sq Ft Roof |
|---|---|---|
| Class 3 asphalt | About $5.60 (statewide average cited in Excel's price guide) | About $14,000 |
| Class 4 asphalt (Duration STORM) | $7.00 to $8.00 | $17,500 to $20,000 |
| Stone-coated steel, direct to deck | $12.75 | $31,875 |
| Stone-coated steel, batten mounted | $13.75 | $34,375 |
Roof pitch, complexity, tear-off layers and decking repairs change the final number. For a full breakdown, see Why Does a New Roof Cost So Much in Colorado? (2026 Price Guide) and How Much Does a New Asphalt Roof Cost in the Denver Area?.
Every Excel Roofing estimate includes Good, Better and Best options so homeowners can compare cost against protection on the same page. For the options in this guide, the tiers look like this.
| Tier | Option | Best Fit For |
|---|---|---|
| Good | Class 3 asphalt | Tight budgets, homes the owner plans to sell soon, and lower-hail areas |
| Better | Class 4 asphalt | Most Front Range homeowners who want hail resistance, insurance credit eligibility and a familiar shingle look |
| Better or Best | Stone-coated steel | Long-term owners in high-hail areas, homes in WUI zones, and buyers who want the longest transferable warranty and above-sheathing ventilation |
For more on vetting contractors, see How to Choose a Residential Roofing Contractor in Colorado.
For most Colorado homes, Class 4 impact-resistant asphalt shingles offer the best balance of hail resistance and cost, while stone-coated steel offers the highest overall durability. Stone-coated steel carries Class 4 ratings, some products also hold an FM 4473 Very Severe Hail rating, and leading lines carry 50-year transferable warranties. The right choice depends on budget, hail exposure and how long the homeowner plans to stay.
In most of Colorado, yes. Colorado typically ranks second nationally for hail insurance claims, and Class 4 shingles are tested with a larger 2-inch steel ball dropped from 20 feet. Many Colorado insurers also offer premium credits for Class 4 roofs. Excel Roofing's 2026 Denver metro price for Class 4 asphalt is $7.00 to $8.00 per square foot installed.
Stone-coated steel is rated Class 4, and some products also carry an FM 4473 Very Severe Hail rating, which is tested at about double the impact energy of Class 4. Very large hail can still leave surface marks or knock off granules without penetrating the steel. Homeowners should review the warranty and their insurance policy for cosmetic damage terms.
Stone-coated steel has a granulated surface that grips snow more like a shingle than a smooth standing seam panel does, so sudden slides are less common than on smooth metal. Snow guards may still be recommended above entries, decks and driveways on steep roofs.
Stone-coated steel installed on battens is typically the most energy efficient of the options in this guide because the air space under the panels vents heat at the ridge before it reaches the attic. For asphalt roofs, balanced attic ventilation and insulation matter more than shingle color. The ENERGY STAR program for roofing products ended in 2022.
Many Colorado insurers offer a premium credit for UL 2218 Class 4 roofs, but the amount varies by carrier, policy and home. Homeowners usually need to request the credit and provide documentation of the roof's rating.
Homes inside designated wildland-urban interface areas do. Under the 2025 Colorado Wildfire Resiliency Code, enforced starting July 1, 2026, covered properties need a Class A fire-rated roof for new construction and when 25% or more of an existing roof covering is replaced.
Leading stone-coated steel products such as Unified Steel carry a 50-year non-prorated, fully transferable warranty, and the manufacturer states the product is designed to last nearly three times longer than asphalt. Asphalt shingles from major manufacturers typically carry limited lifetime warranties, but Colorado hail and UV often shorten their real-world service life.
Seasonal tips for your roof, gutters, windows, and more, plus Excel Roofing specials and hail alerts when storms hit your area. Four issues a year, no spam.
Excel Roofing Inc. has served Colorado and Wyoming homeowners since J Bretz founded the company in 1993. The company has completed over 55,000 projects, holds a 4.9-star rating across 612 Google reviews, is an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor, and won the 2026 BBB Torch Award for Ethics in the large business category for Colorado.
Every inspection ends with a written Good, Better and Best quote that compares Class 3 asphalt, Class 4 asphalt and stone-coated steel side by side, so homeowners can choose the right balance of hail resistance, snow and wind protection, energy performance and budget. And with Excel Roofing's promise, "You Don't Pay A Cent Until You're Content."
Excel Roofing serves homeowners from offices in Englewood and Colorado Springs, Colorado, and Sheridan and Casper, Wyoming. Call (303) 761-6400 or schedule a free inspection at excelroofing.com.
Excel Roofing. We're On Top Of It.
About the author: J Bretz is the Founder and CEO of Excel Roofing, with over 33 years of experience in the roofing industry. He is an Owens Corning Platinum Advisory Board Alumni and a Colorado Roofing Association Board Alumni.